Watercolor landscape, flowing blue and yellow abstract painting, and bold tempera flowers arranged with painting supplies

Watercolor Cakes vs. Liquid Watercolor vs. Tempera

You have a room full of painters, a stack of paper, and three very different ways to get color onto it. The right paint depends on the result you want and how the session will run.

Choose watercolor cakes for compact individual painting stations, liquid watercolor for flowing color and dropper activities, and classroom tempera for bold, more opaque shapes. Compare the actual products’ washability, paper requirements, and dispensing needs before deciding what to stock.

Watercolor vs. tempera: a quick comparison

Format Useful for Setup tradeoff
Watercolor cakes or pans Transparent washes, small paintings, controlled brushwork No liquid paint to portion, but brushes need water and colors need rinsing between them
Liquid watercolor Large washes, dripping, diffusing color, resist activities Ready liquid is easy to distribute; open cups need spill containment
Classroom tempera Bold flowers, posters, broad shapes, stronger coverage Needs palettes or trays, suitable brushes, and space for wet artwork

These are practical tendencies, not identical results across every brand. “Liquid” describes the format; “washable” describes a particular formula. Neither watercolor nor tempera is automatically washable just because it cleans out of a brush with water.

Watercolor cakes: a compact choice for individual work

Cakes and pans hold color in a tray that participants activate with a wet brush. A little water helps pick up stronger color; more water produces a lighter, more transparent wash. They suit spring landscapes, illustrated cards, and brush-control activities.

For groups, the tray keeps the paint supply contained without an adult pouring every color into cups. Participants still need rinse water, a place to blot brushes, and paper suited to the amount of moisture they use. Model “rinse, blot, pick up color” before starting. Otherwise, the yellow pan may quietly become everyone’s brown pan.

Crayola eight-color washable watercolor tray with a paintbrush

EconoCrafts option: Crayola Washable Watercolors – 8 Colors includes eight colors and a paintbrush. It is a useful starting point when you want a contained palette for each painter or pair. Add paper, rinse containers, and table protection.

Pick Your Watercolor Palette


Liquid watercolor: choose it when movement is the activity

Liquid watercolor is already in liquid form, making it useful for brush washes, controlled drops, and color-diffusing activities. Some formulas are used as supplied; others may be diluted. Follow the manufacturer’s directions instead of applying one dilution recipe to every bottle.

A shallow tray under each work surface gives drips somewhere to go. Start with a small portion of two colors and refill as needed. Use a separate dropper or brush for each color to limit accidental mixing in the shared cups.

Adult using a dropper to add yellow liquid watercolor beside a blue wash on paper inside a shallow tray

Best fit: Open-ended color exploration and backgrounds where spreading and blending are welcome. For carefully separated shapes, use a drier surface, less liquid, or another paint format. Do not assume a liquid watercolor is stain-free, suitable for skin painting, or equivalent to a fabric dye; check its label and intended uses.

Classroom tempera: choose it for bold shapes and coverage

This comparison refers to classroom poster-style tempera, not traditional egg tempera. Classroom tempera generally gives a more opaque, matte effect than a watercolor wash. It suits large flower shapes, broad brush marks, and paper artwork that needs strong visible color.

Dispense small portions into palettes and keep rinse water separate. Adding too much water can reduce the coverage you chose tempera for. If your project involves layering, let the first layer dry before adding the next, and check the sample for lifting or muddiness.

Eight bottles of Sargent Art Art-Time washable tempera paint

EconoCrafts option: Sargent Art Washable Tempera Paint – 16 oz (8 Pack) provides eight bottles with flip-top caps. Colors depend on stock. The listing describes washing from most fabrics and skin with soap and water; protect clothing and surfaces and follow the label’s cleanup directions.

Go Bold With Washable Tempera


Choose the paint around your session

  • Short individual painting activity: Watercolor trays reduce advance paint portioning. Set out paper and water before participants arrive.
  • Color-mixing or dropper station: Liquid watercolor makes the movement visible. Keep cups in trays and have an adult manage refills.
  • Large paper display: Tempera is a practical choice for broad, more opaque shapes. Reserve drying space before the first brush is loaded.
  • Mixed abilities or adult programs: Offer brush sizes and paper sizes by preference. A larger working area, a steadier water container, or assistance with dispensing can matter more than changing the paint.

Paper, cleanup, and drying can change the decision

For wet washes, choose watercolor paper or another surface intended for wet media. Thin paper may buckle or weaken under repeated brushing. Diffusing paper is designed to encourage color movement, which is useful for exploration but less suited to a design that needs crisp boundaries.

Drying depends on the paper, paint thickness, water load, and room conditions. Do not promise that one format will be dry before pickup without checking a sample under your own conditions. Label artwork before painting and keep a clear route to the drying area.

Use age-appropriate materials according to the label, supervise tools, and keep paint and rinse water away from food. Washable does not mean intended for face or body painting. Clean brushes promptly, dry them properly, and let watercolor trays dry before closing them.

Compare the cost of a completed session

A bottle price and a palette price do not tell you the cost per participant. Compare the paint used in your sample, the number of participants sharing it, paper needs, preparation, and cleanup. Count usable supplies already on the shelf before ordering.

For a practical check, prepare the same planned activity with each suitable paint using your intended paper and tools. Note how much you dispense, whether the result matches the goal, and what cleanup involves. Do not automatically dilute paint to stretch it if that changes the effect you need.

What should you stock first?

For individual paper paintings, start with watercolor trays. Add liquid watercolor when flowing color is part of the planned activity. Choose tempera when broad, bold coverage is the priority. A well-chosen paint with the right paper will serve the group better than three formats purchased without a project in mind.

For technique guidance, see Crayola’s watercolor techniques and Colorations’ paint-format guidance. Always follow the directions for the specific paint you buy.

Find Your Next Painting Supply

About EconoCrafts

Since 1956, EconoCrafts has helped schools and after-school programs, summer camps, recreation centers, senior centers, nursing homes, hospitals, churches, VBS programs, libraries, and families run successful arts and crafts programs. We supply affordable art supplies, ready-to-use craft kits, and engaging activities that make planning and leading creative projects easier. Whether you’re organizing one classroom activity or an entire season of programming, EconoCrafts helps you spend less time preparing and more time creating.

Shop Arts, Crafts & Activities
Back to blog

Leave a comment