Campers making colorful paper bookmarks while a counselor prepares paper supply packs.

Craft Kits vs. DIY Supply Packs for Summer Camp

Your camp needs three craft sessions a week; the supply closet is already full, and someone has volunteered the counselors to assemble 300 little bags. Before placing the order, decide which preparation jobs your staff can realistically finish.

Choose craft kits when coordinated components remove difficult sourcing or preparation. Make your own supply packs when a tested project uses versatile materials and your team has time to portion them. For a whole summer, combine the two: buy kits for selected specialty projects and share basic supplies across simpler activities.

This guide compares the approaches for camp buyers planning repeated sessions, rotating counselors, and changing attendance. The recommendations are practical planning guidance; the budget below uses invented figures rather than product prices or measured staff times.


What Are You Actually Buying?

A commercial craft kit supplies a specified set of project components. It may serve several campers, and it may still need decorating materials, tools, adhesive, or staff sorting. Check the contents and finished-project count instead of assuming every participant receives a sealed, complete bag.

A DIY supply pack is a set your staff assembles from separate materials for one camper or table. You choose the design, test the instructions, purchase compatible components, portion the materials, and arrange distribution. Shared supplies such as markers can stay in table caddies.

Camp planning question Commercial kits Staff-made supply packs
Who develops the supply list? The kit defines its included components; staff checks extras Staff develops and verifies the full list
What preparation remains? Inspect, make a sample, add extras, and sort if needed Test, cut, count, portion, label, and check sets
How much can you change? Decoration and extensions depend on the project Size, colors, materials, and difficulty are yours to adjust
What happens next week? Unused complete projects can serve another group Suitable bulk materials can support different activities
What can delay the session? Missing extras, complex assembly, or insufficient finished-project count Unfinished packing, mismatched parts, or an unclear supply list

Count Project Uses Across the Summer

Start with the number of times campers will make each project. If 48 campers attend three different craft sessions, plan for 144 project uses. If the same children return next week, they may need new activities. If a fresh group arrives, you may be able to repeat a tested project.

Keep a separate line for each activity and age group. Record expected makers, demonstration samples, planned spares, pack yield, and supplies already reserved for other sessions. Count small components as well as the main craft base: spare paper cannot replace a missing specialty part.

For packs sold in a fixed quantity, add samples and spares before rounding up. A requirement of 54 projects with a 12-project pack means buying five packs for 60 projects. Those six remaining projects are usable stock only if their components stay together.


Compare Purchase Cost and Staff Time Separately

First compare two ways to deliver a similar result for the same group. A sophisticated construction project and a paper bookmark offer different experiences, so their prices alone cannot tell you which purchasing method is more efficient.

Cash purchase total = project materials + extra supplies + packing materials + shipping + applicable tax. Then calculate preparation staff-hours and multiply by an hourly value appropriate for your program. Include receiving, sample-making, sorting, and replenishing table supplies in both options.

Here is a hypothetical comparison covering 144 project uses across three sessions. Both options are assumed to meet the same program goal. All figures are invented, applicable tax is assumed to be zero, and each option includes its own preparation work.

Planning item Kits DIY supply packs
Project materials and decorating extras $324 $180
Packing materials $0 $18
Shipping $18 $18
Cash purchase total $342 $216
Preparation staff-hours 2 hours 6 hours
Time valued at $20 per hour $40 $120
Purchase total plus preparation value $382 $336
Total per project use, rounded $2.65 $2.33

In this example, kits cost $126 more in purchases and save four preparation hours. At the chosen $20 hourly value, DIY packs remain $46 lower overall. The preparation-time value would need to reach $31.50 per hour for the two totals to match, assuming everything else stays equal.

Keep both totals visible. Reassigning four hours of existing staff time can help your program, but it does not automatically reduce payroll or produce cash savings. If those hours would require overtime or an extra shift, use the actual additional cost.


Choose Kits for Parts You Do Not Want to Source

Kits become especially useful when a project relies on coordinated specialty parts. Compare buying those parts separately with checking and preparing the supplied components. Leave time for camper assembly and counselor demonstrations either way.

For example, DIY Paper Kaleidoscopes (12 Pack) include paper tubes, colorful assorted beads, prisms, and plastic end caps. Decorating supplies are sold separately. For a camp science session, that gives your team a defined set of optical-project components to check and prepare.

Unassembled paper kaleidoscope components with white cardboard, reflective strips, plastic end pieces, and colorful beads.

Make a sample and identify the assembly step most likely to need help. Check the package age guidance and small-parts warnings, then decide how many counselors and work trays the session requires. Coordinated parts simplify purchasing; your session plan still needs to cover instruction and supervision.

Shop Kaleidoscopes & Spark Curiosity

Make DIY Packs for Flexible, Repeatable Projects

A paper collage bookmark is a useful example: staff can prepare cardstock blanks and paper scraps while campers choose their own colors and designs. Markers and glue stay shared at the table. One set of versatile supplies can support bookmarks, name cards, and a later collage session, with quantities reserved for each activity.

Hands arranging bookmark blanks and colored paper strips beside an envelope and finished collage bookmarks.

Before scaling up, prepare a small batch and record the work. Separate one-time tasks, such as making the template, from repeated tasks, such as counting paper strips into every set. Two counselors packing for 45 minutes use 1.5 staff-hours, even though only 45 minutes pass on the clock.

  • Keep choices useful: Offer a manageable selection of materials rather than packing every color into every set
  • Label by session: Store the sample, instructions, participant count, and supply list with the activity
  • Plan handoffs: Give substitute counselors enough information to run the session without finding its original designer
  • Adapt before packing: Prepare larger pieces or alternate tools for campers who need them

Check Storage, Leftovers, and the Next Group

Compare shelf space and supply cost. Prepacked sets may speed distribution but occupy more room. Shared bulk stock can be compact until opened packages, half-finished projects, and drying work all need a home. Decide where each stage will live before ordering.

At the end of a session, return reusable tools to shared storage, keep complete spare kits together, and count useful loose materials back into inventory. Record what remains and which future activity will use it. A box of leftovers without a plan can become a very colorful storage fee.

For repeat activities, update the instructions with the step that caused delays, the actual material use, and the help campers needed. That information makes the next purchase comparison more useful than either option’s advertised convenience.


Build a Mix Your Counselors Can Run

Choose kits for the specialty sessions where coordinating components would absorb your preparation time. Build DIY packs for familiar activities that use existing stock well. Keep a simple drawing or collage option ready for attendance changes and schedule disruptions, with its materials reserved.

Before approving the order, confirm project counts, extras, delivery timing, preparation ownership, and storage. Browse craft kits and project packs alongside art supplies, then choose the combination your team can prepare and lead well.

Shop Camp Crafts for a Summer of Making

About EconoCrafts

Since 1956, EconoCrafts has helped schools and after-school programs, summer camps, recreation centers, senior centers, nursing homes, hospitals, churches, VBS programs, libraries, and families run successful arts and crafts programs. We supply affordable art supplies, ready-to-use craft kits, and engaging activities that make planning and leading creative projects easier. Whether you’re organizing one classroom activity or an entire season of programming, EconoCrafts helps you spend less time preparing and more time creating.

Shop Arts, Crafts & Activities
Back to blog

Leave a comment